LL Bean $199.
It seems that most of you liked the J. Crew coat and assumed it was the most expensive. I love the J. Crew coat and am happy that it is a reasonable $255.
The Polo was the least favorite and the most expensive.
I was pleasantly surprised with the styling of the LL Bean and was a bit surprised that it was so close in price to the J. Crew coat.
As usual, J. Crew wins with me and it seems with you too!